Herbals and cancer drugs - a dangerous combination?
alleviate symptoms, new research demonstrates that some herbals can
prevent synthetic drugs from working. St John's wort may reduce the
effectiveness of the chemotherapy drug irinotecan.
Researchers in the Netherlands have found that the herbal dietary supplement St John's wort interferes with the metabolism, and potentially the effectiveness of the chemotherapy drug irinotecan.
St John's wort (Hypericum perforatum L.) is widely used to treat mild to moderate forms of depression. Past studies have suggested that the compound increases levels of CYP3A4, an enzyme involved in drug metabolism. The enzyme inactivates the colorectal cancer chemotherapy drug irinotecan.
To examine the interaction between St John's wort's and irinotecan, Dr Ron Mathijssen and Dr Alex Sparreboom of the Department of Medical Oncology at the Erasmus MC-Daniel den Hoed Cancer Center, and their colleagues treated five patients with irinotecan alone or in combination with St John's wort.
At the end of the study, blood levels of SN-38 (the active metabolite of irinotecan) were 42 per cent lower in patients receiving irinotecan and St John's wort than when the patients received irinotecan alone. Detoxification of the drug to other known metabolites also decreased with St John's wort.
"Our findings suggest that irinotecan metabolism and toxicity are altered by [St John's wort] and that the two agents cannot be given safely in combination without compromising overall antitumour activity," the authors wrote.
They noted that their results may have implications for other anticancer drugs metabolised by CYP3A4, such as the taxanes (paclitaxel). Combining these drugs with St John's wort may make it necessary to increase drug dosage to achieve the optimal pharmacologic effect.
"Until specific dosing guidelines are available, it is strongly recommended that patients receiving chemotherapeutic treatments with such agents refrain from taking St John's wort," they concluded.
In a related editorial, Dr Patrick Mansky and Dr Stephen Straus of the National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine at the National Institutes of Health, pointed out that cancer patients are among the most likely to seek complementary and alternative medical remedies to reduce the side effects of treatments.
They said that, in addition to St John's wort, a number of herbal remedies have been found to affect synthetic drug metabolism and, potentially, drug efficacy.
The National Institutes of Health is funding studies of complementary and alternative medicine practices in cancer patients. While waiting for these results, "it would be prudent for patients and their oncologists to appreciate that, no matter how beneficial some approaches may appear to be, they are not all safe," the authors noted.
Their study is published in today's issue of the Journal of the National Cancer Institute.
