Kemin refutes Frost & Sullivan lutein claims

By Shane Starling

- Last updated on GMT

Related tags: Macular degeneration

Kemin Health says Frost & Sullivan statements that astaxanthin can benefit age-related macular degeneration with less per-day doses than lutein hasve no scientific backing.

The formula – Eye Pro MD – is delivered via a proprietary omega-3/phospholipid delivery system and also contains vitamin D3.

The CARMIS (Carotenoids and Antioxidant in Age Related Maculopathy Italian Study) was reported in Ophthalmology​ in 2008.

The evidence is still mounting, but it appears different carotenoids function very differently in the eye, something that has been debated vigorously by those in the carotenoids business, and something a Valensa president Rudi Moerck acknowledged.

"The CARMIS study that employed astaxanthin as a key component suggests that it is an excellent addition to eye healthcare supplements that already contain lutein and zeaxanthin,”​ he said in a statement.

“Lutein is known to accumulate in the outer region of the macula, where light impingement is relatively low in comparison to the central macular region (also known as the fovea), where the highest light impingement always occurs and where maximum antioxidant protection is required.”

“…astaxanthin can be considered the first line of defense and should, in fact, allow the other ingredients to function more effectively.”

Valensa said it was designing a “multi-arm eye healthcare clinical trial”​ that would in part study the benefits of astaxanthin on its own as well as in conjunction with other carotenoids and omega-3 delivery systems.


While lutein, zeaxanthin, and astaxanthin have failed to impress Food and Drug Administration (FDA) or European Food Safety Authority (EFSA) scientists in regard to their eye health-benefitting potential, claims have been approved such as two lutein claims in France.

They read:

‘Lutein helps protect the retina and the lens from oxidation’

‘Lutein is one (of the) constituents of the retina and the lens’

Related news

Show more

Related products

show more

Give joint health consumers what they want

Give joint health consumers what they want

Lonza | 01-Nov-2022 | Technical / White Paper

It’s no secret the pandemic had a profound effect on the way we live and move. Consumers of all ages now want to get back to doing the things they love,...

Related suppliers

Follow us


View more