Breaking News on Supplements & Nutrition - North AmericaEU edition

Headlines > Research

Loading...

Nutrition research paradigm needs to change for nutrigenomics: Expert

2 commentsBy Stephen Daniells, 02-Aug-2010

Related topics: Research, Nutrigenomics

Interview with Jim Kaput, PhD
Director, Division of Personalized Nutrition and Medicine, US Food and Drug Administration

At the recent IFT Annual Meeting and Expo, Stephen Daniells talked to Dr Jim Kaput, director of FDA’s Division of Personalized Nutrition and Medicine about the paradigm shift needed to move personalized nutrition forward.

The current research approach of grouping people together is not in-keeping with personalized nutrition, said Dr Kaput. “You have to think of a new paradigm: How do you conduct the research in order to get to the individual risk factor or the individual benefit factor for blueberries, or blackberries, or whatever food you are looking at.”

The advances in the field of nutrigenomics today do have significant implications for the food industry, said Dr Kaput: “We need to understand the mechanism by which the nutrients in food can alter health, and from that we can tell the food manufacturers what to put in their products.”

“We need to be more science-based when we talk to the food manufacturers so we can design better foods. We have to be realistic, we definitely need manufactured foods, but we have to manufacture them the right way,” he added.

The views expressed in this video are those of Jim Kaput and not those of the FDA.

2 comments (Comments are now closed)

Great interview

The low fat craze of the mid-80's was in response to the increase in obesity, not the cause. Otherwise, Dr. Kaput's views are spot on regarding how premature the nutrigenomics promise really is. Different polymorphisms may each affect only a small % of people, but when one person has several that overlap, we've got an interesting nutrigenomic situation. However, the real push should be epigenetics, as some recent obesity research indicates. Love the quote: Food design by newspaper article. So true!

Report abuse

Posted by Donna Feldman
31 August 2010 | 20h02

Personalized gene testing not needed

Personalized nutrition based upon genomics is not needed. Structural problems with genes (mutations) represent only 2% of inherited disease. There are gene polymorphisms and mutations that affect such broad human populations (mutated gene for gulonolactone oxidase to convert blood sugar to vitamin C; Asians exhibit lack of haptoglobin and need more vitamin C; large groups are unable to properly metabolize folic acid; dark-skinned populations poorly synthesize vitamin D from solar radiation exposure), which suggests widespread food fortification or supplementation with no gene testing needed. We now live in an era of epigenetics, where we have learned how to switch genes on and off. We need to shift from the outmoded paradigm of disease genomes to mimicking the gene expression profile of health. The unequivocal model of health and longevity is a limited-calorie diet which can be molecularly mimicked with small molecules found in grapes, berries, bran, spices. This should be the primary objective of nutrition in this new century -- to delay the onset of aging via anti-aging technology, and thus save health care systems from financial collapse.

Report abuse

Posted by Bill Sardi
02 August 2010 | 18h04

IPA co-founder: EU probiotic approach is “dirty pool”

IPA co-founder: EU probiotic approach is “dirty pool”

Jarrow Rogovin

President and owner, Jarrow Formulas

Researchers close in on the ‘black box’ of bacterial vaginosis

Researchers close in on the ‘black box’ of bacterial vaginosis

Dr Jacques Ravel

Associate professor , The University of Maryland’s Institute of Genome...

NDI comments review: Industry urges FDA back to the drawing board

NDI comments review: Industry urges FDA back to the drawing board

One week on from the deadline for submission of comments on the FDA’s new...

Stepan ends years of North American isolationism with strategic European nutrition shift

Stepan ends years of North American isolationism with strategic European nutrition shift

Emile Henein

Global business manager, Stepan Lipid Nutrition

Are Millennials the next big opportunity for the natural product industry?

Are Millennials the next big opportunity for the natural product industry?

Jeff Hilton

President and co-founder, Integrated Marketing Group (IMG)

Imminent ‘seed event’ set to expose dry labbing issues?

Imminent ‘seed event’ set to expose dry labbing issues?

Frank Jaksch

CEO and co-counder, Chromadex

Scalable new sources of omega-3 key to success for algae oils

Scalable new sources of omega-3 key to success for algae oils

Leslie van der Meulen

VP Business Development, AuroraAlgae

NDI draft guidance release is ‘curious timing’: BI chief

NDI draft guidance release is ‘curious timing’: BI chief

George Pontiakos

President and CEO, BI Nutraceuticals

GOED explains its “big plans” for omega-3 health claims in 2012

GOED explains its “big plans” for omega-3 health claims in 2012

With the volume of omega-3 science tripling in 10 years, the world’s leading omega-3...

US businesses face rude shock as EU health claims laws loom

US businesses face rude shock as EU health claims laws loom

Martin Last

Chairman , UK Health Food Manufacturer’s Association (HFMA)

Horphag Research: We're going after sports nutrition and women's health

Horphag Research: We're going after sports nutrition and women's health

Markus Beba

VP Sales & Business Development, Horphag Research

Fabricant: Gap between NDI numbers and submissions is too big 'no matter how you slice it'

Fabricant: Gap between NDI numbers and submissions is too big 'no matter how you slice it'

Daniel Fabricant, PhD

Director of the Division of Dietary Supplement Programs, Food and...

The Beauty From Within Conference is back with a packed programme!

The second Beauty From Within conference will open its doors in Paris on October...

Simplicity trend 'is the future': Marketing expert

Simplicity trend 'is the future': Marketing expert

Jeff Hilton

Partner and co-founder, Integrated Marketing Group (IMG)

Functional foods: How to get more bang for your buck

Functional foods: How to get more bang for your buck

George Pontiakos

Chief executive, BI Nutraceuticals

US Army ‘concerned’ over excessive supplement use amongst soldiers

US Army ‘concerned’ over excessive supplement use amongst soldiers

Edward Zambraski, PhD

Division Chief, Military Performance Division, US Army Research Institute...

The next superfruit: Sea buckthorn and its elusive omega-7

The next superfruit: Sea buckthorn and its elusive omega-7

Jeff Hilton

Partner and co-founder , Integrated Marketing Group (IMG)

BASF 'impressed' with Cognis integration, expecting more M&A

BASF 'impressed' with Cognis integration, expecting more M&A

Samy Jandali

VP of nutrition and health North America, BASF

WWF on krill: "World’s largest under-exploited fishery"

WWF on krill: "World’s largest under-exploited fishery"

Nina Jensen, conservation director at the World Wildlife Fund, Norway

Matts Johansen, executive vice president for sales and marketing, Aker...

New dosage forms drive supplements growth but is social media helping?

New dosage forms drive supplements growth but is social media helping?

Jeff Hilton

Co-founder, Integrated Marketing Group

‘We have to look to different sources’ says GOED chief as omega-3 sectors unite

‘We have to look to different sources’ says GOED chief as omega-3 sectors unite

Sandra Gillot, owner and general manager, Benexia

Baldur Hjaltsun, chairman of the Global Organization for EPA and...

The courting of POM Wonderful and the FTC – a love story

The courting of POM Wonderful and the FTC – a love story

Marc Ullman, Ullman, Shapiro and Ullman;

James Prochnow, Greenberg Traurig

A transatlantic view of regulations and health claims

A transatlantic view of regulations and health claims

Andrew Shao, PhD

senior vice president, scientific and regulatory affairs, Council for Responsible...

Raised vitamin D recommendations 'a step in the right direction'

Raised vitamin D recommendations 'a step in the right direction'

Andrew Shao, PhD

senior vice president, scientific and regulatory affairs, Council for Responsible...

Improving perceptions of oat beta glucans

Improving perceptions of oat beta glucans

David Peters

Head of Business Development, Biovelop

Lessons to learn from trans-Atlantic partnerships

Lessons to learn from trans-Atlantic partnerships

Jeremy Moore

Global business director, Stratum Nutrition

Suicide stats could lead US military's omega-3s charge

Suicide stats could lead US military's omega-3s charge

Adam Ismail

Executive director , GOED

Where immune health meets sports nutrition

Where immune health meets sports nutrition

Larry Robinson, PhD.

Vice president, scientific affairs , Embria

Ocean Spray backed research reveals cranberry polyphenols in human urine

Ocean Spray backed research reveals cranberry polyphenols in human urine

Professor Jeffrey Blumberg

Director, Antioxidants Research Laboratory, Tufts University

The father of nutraceuticals: “The placebo effect is real”

The father of nutraceuticals: “The placebo effect is real”

Dr Stephen de Felice

Founder and chairman, Foundation for Innovation in Medicine

WWF backs krill fishery as new data and better harvest methods surface

WWF backs krill fishery as new data and better harvest methods surface

Karoline Andaur

Head of the marine programme, World Wildlife Fund Norway

DRI president leads 2012 dairy charge to spotlight ‘total nutrient package’

DRI president leads 2012 dairy charge to spotlight ‘total nutrient package’

Gregory Miller PhD

President, Dairy Research Institute (DRI)

Ingredient suppliers grasping opportunity inside Asia’s many markets

Ingredient suppliers grasping opportunity inside Asia’s many markets

Bram van Hulsen, regional director, Asia Pacific, Danisco BioActives

Henning Villadsen, sales director, Asia Pacific, Middle East and Africa,...

Three gut types may have functional differences, says researcher

Three gut types may have functional differences, says researcher

Jeroen Raes

professor of bioinformatics and systems biology, University of Brussels and...

Metagenomic data evolves vitamin E science

Metagenomic data evolves vitamin E science

Dr Peter Weber

Corporate scientist , DSM Nutritional Products

Probiotics could boost immune functions in athletes, says Prof

Probiotics could boost immune functions in athletes, says Prof

Mike Gleeson

professor of sport, exercise and health sciences, Loughborough University

Food-pharma convergence? Keep an eye on Nestlé, says nutrition professor

Food-pharma convergence? Keep an eye on Nestlé, says nutrition professor

Renger Witkamp

Professor of Nutrition and Pharmacology, Wageningen University

Ganeden on 'predatory lawsuits', probiotic tea and the Walmart snowball effect

Ganeden on 'predatory lawsuits', probiotic tea and the Walmart snowball effect

Elaine Watson caught up with Ganeden Biotech's business development boss Mike Bush at the...

Easy as ABC: Botanicals body launches fightback vs economic adulteration

Easy as ABC: Botanicals body launches fightback vs economic adulteration

Mark Blumenthal

Founder and executive director, American Botanical Council (ABC)

What makes a successful functional food product?

What makes a successful functional food product?

Why do so many ‘functional’ foods fail? Sometimes, it’s just bad luck or bad...

Using modern science to re-assess traditional ingredients: Vitafoods preview

Using modern science to re-assess traditional ingredients: Vitafoods preview

Dr Martin Wickham

Head of Nutrition, Leatherhead Food Research

Naturex set for “one or two” acquisitions in 2011: President

Naturex set for “one or two” acquisitions in 2011: President

Jacques Dikansky

President and chief executive officer, Naturex

In search of lutein eye health biomarkers

In search of lutein eye health biomarkers

Professor B Randall Hammond

Professor, Psychology dept, University of Georgia

Bruker-Chromadex deal 'exciting opportunity for industry'

Mark Jost

VP corporate development, Chromadex

NPA getting ‘good feedback’ from Congressional freshmen

NPA getting ‘good feedback’ from Congressional freshmen

John Gay

Executive director, Natural Products Association

Different generations seek similar functions from functional foods

Jeff Hilton

President and co-founder, Integrated Marketing Group

NSF: MHA not a constituent of geranium oil

Ed Wyszumiala

General manager, Dietary supplements Programs, NSF International

The uncertain future of relaxation drinks

Jim Tonkin

President , HealthyBrandBuilders

Geranium oil issues beginning to ‘bubble over’ into public domain

Anthony Almada

President and CEO, GENr8, Inc.

Getting a taste for DSM's Nutrition Improvement Program

Oswaldo da Costa e Silva

VP Nutrition Improvement Program, DSM Nutritional Products

Scottish islands selected for new vitamin D study

Scottish islands selected for new vitamin D study

Dr Ruth McQuillan

University of Edinburgh

Weight management success shows sports nutrition potential

Weight management success shows sports nutrition potential

Loren Ward

Director of R&D, Glanbia Nutritionals

Snack Size Science: Probiotics for dummies

Snack Size Science: Probiotics for dummies

NutraIngredient’s Snack Size Science brings you the week's top science every two weeks. This...

Beauty from Within 2010 conference is Monday

Beauty from Within 2010 conference is Monday

The Beauty from Within conference, brought to you by CosmeticsDesign-Europe.com and NutraIngredients.com, is only...

Nestlé enters functional foods ring as claims climate heats up

Nestlé enters functional foods ring as claims climate heats up

Chairman of the Board, Peter Brabeck-Letmathe; Nestlé chief executive officer,...

Snack Size Science: Cranberry’s promise for prostates

Snack Size Science: Cranberry’s promise for prostates

NutraIngredient’s Snack Size Science brings you the week's top science every two weeks. This...

Snack Size Science: Ahoy to omega-3 from soy

Snack Size Science: Ahoy to omega-3 from soy

NutraIngredient’s Snack Size Science brings you the week's top science every two weeks. This...