Breaking News on Supplements & Nutrition - North AmericaEU edition

News > Regulation

Loading...

Is finished product testing the next big wave in GMP warning letters?

By Stephen DANIELLS , 14-Nov-2012

Once GMP inspectors from the FDA move beyond the first tier of GMP compliance, the next big wave of warning letters from the agency could be on the issue of finished product testing, says a leading quality and regulatory expert.

Aaron Secrist, Quality & Regulatory Manager for NOW Foods, told NutraIngredients-USA at the SupplySide West show in Las Vegas last week that, as the inspectors gain more experience and move beyond the first tier GMP compliance issues, they are going to start ask a whole new set of questions.

“Instead of, ‘Are you are doing finished product testing?’ the questions will be, ‘How are you testing? What are you testing? What are you not testing? What is your rationale for not testing?’” said Secrist.

We’ve already seen warning letters from the FDA this year for basic GMP non-compliance issues, and so is the industry ready for the next tier of inspections?

“I think some in the industry are more ready than others,” said Secrist. “I think one of the issues we face in this industry is a real lack of analytical methods and even some standards. Everything in analytical chemistry comes back to the standards.”

“Without the standards and methods in place, it is going to be very hard for the Agency to test these products and determine if they are meeting their finished products specifications.”

“The FDA needs to look at categories of products and start doing a lot of their own work to determine whether or not these products meet their specifications.

“It’s going to require a significant amount of development work on their end, since you don’t find these published in the literature.

“The other difficulty they are going to run into is that every company’s products are slightly different. The make-up of the product, the matrix, is different. Yes, they’re all multivitamins, but some have botanicals and some don’t, all of those things can make it very difficult for companies as well as the agency to test these products.”

Getting on with it: How a big US supplements maker adapts to major EU law changes

Getting on with it: How a big US supplements maker adapts to major EU law changes

Morgan Coghill

European account manager, Now International

Roquette outsources lab to food supplements makers

Roquette outsources lab to food supplements makers

Olaf Häusler PhD

Pharmaceutical project and development manager , Roquette pharmaceutical and cosmetics...

IADSA chair spells out global GMP progress

IADSA chair spells out global GMP progress

Peter Zambetti

Global business development director, Capsugel; , Chairman, IADSA (International Association...

Time for mandatory folic acid fortification to go truly global?

Time for mandatory folic acid fortification to go truly global?

Dr Klaus Kraemer

Director, sightandlife

In vitro data still has an important place in EFSA dossiers, says expert

In vitro data still has an important place in EFSA dossiers, says expert

Industry must not drop interest in mechanism focused, lab-based, in vitro studies in favour...

EFSA sets standard for study rigor, consultant says

EFSA sets standard for study rigor, consultant says

Joerg Gruenwald PhD

President, analyze & realize

Trend-spotter: The rise of slow-energy

Trend-spotter: The rise of slow-energy

David Jago

Director of innovation, Mintel

Delivering on the personalized nutrition promise

Delivering on the personalized nutrition promise

Dilip Ghosh PhD, FACN

Director, NutriConnect

Global healthcare systems are failing; nutrition policy needs to change now, says leading academic

Global healthcare systems are failing; nutrition policy needs to change now, says leading academic

Paul Clayton

Professor, Oxford University Institute of Food Brain & Behaviour

Happy holidays from William Reed Business Media!

Happy holidays from William Reed Business Media!

The working year is almost done, time to pause from ‘the business’ and embrace...

New models hold promise for probiotic claim substantiation

New models hold promise for probiotic claim substantiation

Alwine Kardinaal

Senior researcher for health and nutrition, Nizo Food Research

DuPont on EU probiotic health claim ban: “Mention specific strains”

DuPont on EU probiotic health claim ban: “Mention specific strains”

Michael Bond

Health platform leader in Active Nutrition, DuPont Nutrition and Health

'You can feel the difference in half an hour...' PLT on why Zembrin could be a blockbuster

'You can feel the difference in half an hour...' PLT on why Zembrin could be a blockbuster

One of the most interesting new product launches at Supply Side West last week...

GMP compliance levels are ‘all over the place’: Alkemists CEO

GMP compliance levels are ‘all over the place’: Alkemists CEO

Elan Sudberg

CEO , Alkemists Laboratories

Global population demands, ‘confusing’ media coverage and the 100 year old vitamin

Global population demands, ‘confusing’ media coverage and the 100 year old vitamin

Deshanie Rai, PhD

Senior Scientific Leader, Human Nutrition & Health , DSM Nutritional Products

Arla says UHT-friendly whey can tackle elderly malnutrition

Arla says UHT-friendly whey can tackle elderly malnutrition

Vivian Kjaer Jensen

Business development manager , Arla Food Ingredients

How to show a clinical trial benefit in healthy populations

How to show a clinical trial benefit in healthy populations

Jay Udani, MD

Founder & CEO , Medicus Research

Roquette seeks sports blends for pea protein

Roquette seeks sports blends for pea protein

Aurélie Mauray-Soulier, PhD

Market development manager, Roquette

Sourcing non-GMO: Prop 37 supporters have lost the battle, but may ultimately win the war, predicts The Scoular Company

Sourcing non-GMO: Prop 37 supporters have lost the battle, but may ultimately win the war, predicts The Scoular Company

Despite the ‘NO’ vote on Prop 37, the momentum behind sourcing non-GMO ingredients remains...

Regulatory momentum to continue for dietary supplements industry: CRN’s Mister

Regulatory momentum to continue for dietary supplements industry: CRN’s Mister

Steve Mister

President and CEO, Council for Responsible Nutrition (CRN)

Functional foodstuffs: The challenge of omega-3 in finished products

Functional foodstuffs: The challenge of omega-3 in finished products

Dr Rob Winwood

Manager Scientific Communications , DSM Nutritional Products

Customized nutrition driving growth in healthcare practitioner channel

Customized nutrition driving growth in healthcare practitioner channel

Jeff Hilton

Chief Marketing Officer, Co-founder, Integrated Marketing Group (IMG)

‘Mini gut’ technology aims to make probiotic research more efficient and cheaper, says TNO

‘Mini gut’ technology aims to make probiotic research more efficient and cheaper, says TNO

A new technology that utilises intestinal stem cells to grown mini gut structures in...

New technologies and academic collaborations will drive evidence and market growth for probiotics

New technologies and academic collaborations will drive evidence and market growth for probiotics

Greater collaboration from both within the industry, and between industry and academics, will help...

The data jungle: Matching gene content to probiotic traits could offer industry fresh hope

The data jungle: Matching gene content to probiotic traits could offer industry fresh hope

The probiotic industry is fighting several big fights at the minute, not least in...

Re-forming resveratrol: Bioavailability issues are no more as researchers reveal metabolites regenerate

Re-forming resveratrol: Bioavailability issues are no more as researchers reveal metabolites regenerate

Metabolites from the break-down of resveratrol have been shown to come together and regenerate...

Is the ‘red wine compound’ tag damaging to resveratrol?

Is the ‘red wine compound’ tag damaging to resveratrol?

Is the association between resveratrol and red wine beneficial for the compound, or could...

BASF nutrition president on high-end omega-3, Equateq and the phood “white space”

BASF nutrition president on high-end omega-3, Equateq and the phood “white space”

Walter Dissinger

President , BASF nutrition and health

Resveratrol and cancer: The study behind the headlines

Resveratrol and cancer: The study behind the headlines

Last week saw widespread media coverage of research suggesting resveratrol – often referred to...

Pharma-food gap will be bridged, but taste is always key: Nestlé

Pharma-food gap will be bridged, but taste is always key: Nestlé

Dr Thomas Beck

head of the Nestle Research Centre, Nestle

Omega-3 suppliers must know their consumers

Omega-3 suppliers must know their consumers

Omega-3 suppliers must get to grips with their manufacturing customers and with consumers if...

New research unit will help Nestlé quest for health claims gold

New research unit will help Nestlé quest for health claims gold

Rafael Crabbé

head of Clinical Development Unit, Nestlé

EndoSeaRch: A new way to modify gut health?

EndoSeaRch: A new way to modify gut health?

Professor Simon Best

CEO, Aquapharm

Ocean Spray backed research reveals cranberry polyphenols in human urine

Ocean Spray backed research reveals cranberry polyphenols in human urine

Professor Jeffrey Blumberg

Director, Antioxidants Research Laboratory, Tufts University

The father of nutraceuticals: “The placebo effect is real”

The father of nutraceuticals: “The placebo effect is real”

Dr Stephen de Felice

Founder and chairman, Foundation for Innovation in Medicine

WWF backs krill fishery as new data and better harvest methods surface

WWF backs krill fishery as new data and better harvest methods surface

Karoline Andaur

Head of the marine programme, World Wildlife Fund Norway

DRI president leads 2012 dairy charge to spotlight ‘total nutrient package’

DRI president leads 2012 dairy charge to spotlight ‘total nutrient package’

Gregory Miller PhD

President, Dairy Research Institute (DRI)

Ingredient suppliers grasping opportunity inside Asia’s many markets

Ingredient suppliers grasping opportunity inside Asia’s many markets

Bram van Hulsen, regional director, Asia Pacific, Danisco BioActives

Henning Villadsen, sales director, Asia Pacific, Middle East and Africa,...

Three gut types may have functional differences, says researcher

Three gut types may have functional differences, says researcher

Jeroen Raes

professor of bioinformatics and systems biology, University of Brussels and...

Metagenomic data evolves vitamin E science

Metagenomic data evolves vitamin E science

Dr Peter Weber

Corporate scientist , DSM Nutritional Products

Probiotics could boost immune functions in athletes, says Prof

Probiotics could boost immune functions in athletes, says Prof

Mike Gleeson

professor of sport, exercise and health sciences, Loughborough University

Food-pharma convergence? Keep an eye on Nestlé, says nutrition professor

Food-pharma convergence? Keep an eye on Nestlé, says nutrition professor

Renger Witkamp

Professor of Nutrition and Pharmacology, Wageningen University

Ganeden on 'predatory lawsuits', probiotic tea and the Walmart snowball effect

Ganeden on 'predatory lawsuits', probiotic tea and the Walmart snowball effect

Elaine Watson caught up with Ganeden Biotech's business development boss Mike Bush at the...

Easy as ABC: Botanicals body launches fightback vs economic adulteration

Easy as ABC: Botanicals body launches fightback vs economic adulteration

Mark Blumenthal

Founder and executive director, American Botanical Council (ABC)

What makes a successful functional food product?

What makes a successful functional food product?

Why do so many ‘functional’ foods fail? Sometimes, it’s just bad luck or bad...

Using modern science to re-assess traditional ingredients: Vitafoods preview

Using modern science to re-assess traditional ingredients: Vitafoods preview

Dr Martin Wickham

Head of Nutrition, Leatherhead Food Research

Naturex set for “one or two” acquisitions in 2011: President

Naturex set for “one or two” acquisitions in 2011: President

Jacques Dikansky

President and chief executive officer, Naturex

In search of lutein eye health biomarkers

In search of lutein eye health biomarkers

Professor B Randall Hammond

Professor, Psychology dept, University of Georgia

Bruker-Chromadex deal 'exciting opportunity for industry'

Mark Jost

VP corporate development, Chromadex